The Fog Clears, but what about redshift?

[PlasmaKid]

Hasn't the redshift controversy been put to rest? http://scientopia.org/blogs/galacticint ... redshifts/ claims that studies done to verify Arp's work find, well, nothing. http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2005ApJ...633...41T Is one such study which took his work seriously and couldn't find any of these troubling quasars and their redshift discrepencies (or so the article claims)

Is the redshift problem so important to EU&PC? Isn't it more of a Big Bang related issue? Also, I am far from an expert on this, (I did read Quasars, Redshifts, and Controversies) but it doesnt seem like Arp has made the greatest case for his theories... To me it seems entirely based on statistics & probabilities and less on actual verifiable evidence.

Thoughts?

PK

[Goldminer]

Hasn't the redshift controversy been put to rest? http://scientopia.org/blogs/galacticint ... redshifts/ claims that studies done to verify Arp's work find, well, nothing. http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2005ApJ...633...41T Is one such study which took his work seriously and couldn't find any of these troubling quasars and their redshift discrepencies (or so the article claims)

Is the redshift problem so important to EU&PC? Isn't it more of a Big Bang related issue? Also, I am far from an expert on this, (I did read Quasars, Redshifts, and Controversies) but it doesnt seem like Arp has made the greatest case for his theories... To me it seems entirely based on statistics & probabilities and less on actual verifiable evidence.

Thoughts?

PK

Your first link is actually about whether Siggy and Gordon Lamps understand what Neirid and Rob have to say, and vice versa. When consensus thinkers set out to prove that Halton Arp is wrong, they feign to understand the process necessary to find the Mother galaxy and the children. Consequently when none are found by their self invented method, they jump with glee that they have proven intrinsic red shift wrong. How silly they look when the proper method still shows intrinsic red shift! This discussion and links are posted here on Tbolt forum already.